Note: this is NOT investment advice. The ETFs and sustainability indexes referred to in this article are not the only ones available. The author is not aware of a simple way to find indexes and ETFs that match your sustainability and investment preferences, apart from the responsible use of AI and web searches. Always check fees. If in doubt, seek professional financial advice.
I agree with George Monbiot that investing in renewables is great for the UK's energy security. But your financial adviser is unlikely to ask you your views on solar panels, batteries, and heat pumps. The most you can hope for are three or four questions: your attitude to risk; your preference for active or passive investing; your ESG/sustainability preference; and your preference for specific countries or themes. Neither are you likely to be asked what future you hope for, beyond growth versus value... nothing imaginative like which Arup scenario you want to invest in, or your interest in themes such as the circular economy, electrification, or ecosystem restoration projects.
There is a fifth question that is not always asked: what level of fees and decision-making are you comfortable with? Having spent a big chunk of my career developing passive ETFs, whose ethos is for low fees and investor choice, this strikes me as a fairly central question. But we also know that passive investing leads to all sorts of distortions, not least the bloated flotation of Thus PLC at the height of the DotCom bubble; and that the world is awash with USD dollars that, in turn, are feeding the US and AI stock bubbles.
So with this caveat - that markets are distorted and unpredictable - what should we do? If we want to invest sustainably, should we outsource our decision-making to others - wealth managers, active funds, and financial advisers - or is there still a place for passive ETFs?
Let's start with the FCA evidence: higher fees lead to worse performance, whereas passive investment leads to over-weighting of some stocks/sectors and a weakening of stewardship, governance and capital allocation. Rather than outsource our decisions, we could instead develop a low-cost base with passive ETFs, and then tackle each of these issues ourselves. To improve stewardship and governance, we could opt for sustainability indexes (benchmarks with stronger stewardship and governance). We could include bonds to match our personal risk preferences, including green bonds. Lastly, to improve the allocation of capital, we could specifically allocate to countries, communities and themes that align with our own interests.
Q1: sustainability preference. We start by choosing sustainability indexes that match our preference for stronger stewardship and governance, including emissions reductions. Here, I am using the MSCI ESG indexes, which start with ESG Aware (tilts towards improved firms) and move through ESG Screened (the exclusion of controversial sectors such as tobacco and thermal coal, and firm targets to reduce carbon intensity by around 30%) towards ESG Leaders and SRI (stricter screening and a 50% emissions reduction target). Our starting position is then 100% in our ESG index of choice, based on the MSCI All World Index.
So, if our sustainability preference is low, we could blend the iShares ESG Aware MSCI EAFE ETF and iShares ESG Aware MSCI USA ETF; if it is medium, we could instead start with the iShares MSCI World Screened UCITS ETF, and if it is high, we could opt for the Xtrackers MSCI World ESG UCITS ETF:
![]() |
Q2: attitude to risk. Putting 100% into a tilted version of the MSCI All World is high risk, though. For starters, we'll be at the whim of equity markets. We'll also be overweight the US and some sectors, including AI. Let's start by reducing the equity risk.
Low risk - if we are truly low risk, we'd not invest at all, until we've reduced our debts
Medium risk - the traditional mix, a 60/40 equity/bond portfolio is not entirely dead, although equity risk has been a better hedge for recent inflation. But bonds create an opportunity for capital allocation, so we could include sustainability-aligned community energy bonds via an Ethex IFISA, or tax-free NS&I green savings bonds. Alternatively, UK/domestic gilts are the basis of steady cashflows: 0-5 year bonds for the short-term, or all maturity bonds for the longer-term. If you want extra market and FX risk, include corporate or overseas bonds. Or, if you want to keep things simple and liquid, include Premium Bonds.
High risk - if you really think this time is different, don't bother with bonds at all, but max out your property loans and credit cards and use the leverage to invest more than 100% in your preferred MSCI ESG index. Don't come crying to me, though, if the equity markets blow up just as you need your cash.
Q3: your preference for specific themes. I'm assuming by now that you've chosen your MSCI ESG index and decided what percentage to put into bonds. This leaves one more opportunity to bring in additional ETF themes, which will diversify further and give you a reason to read the FT every day. Take your pick from:
Country/region themes - it's easier to add a country, by buying a country/region ETF, than to subtract. Some ETF bases exclude countries or whole regions, such as the iShares ESG Aware MSCI EAFE ETF, which excludes the US and Canada, and is one of the few ways to underweight US AI stocks.
Other themes. There are plenty of thematic and impact ETFs out there. Missing still are the smaller cap stocks. If you trade too often, you'll push up your transaction fees. I try to re-balance annually, to keep my transaction costs down. That also forces me to be more like Warren Buffett: invest in themes where I have a connection or interest. This is your chance to defeat the index ETFs, and bring about the transition you want to see...not just sustainable energy but also sustainable food, the circular economy, electrification, commodities, green infrastructure, emerging and developing markets, nature restoration, charities, farms, social enterprises... just remember... caveat emptor!



