Thursday, 19 November 2026

Money won't matter on a dead planet

Note: this is NOT investment advice - if in doubt, speak to a financial adviser. The ETFs referred to in this article are not the only products available - they were found using a mix of website and Google searches, including the FT.COM, and MSCI website. The author is not aware of any simple way to filter ETFs by the suggested criteria of sustainability preference and themes, apart from web and platform searches. If in doubt, seek professional financial advice.

I agree with George Monbiot that investing in renewables is great for the UK's energy security. But your financial adviser is unlikely to ask you about renewables. The most you can hope for are three or four questions: your attitude to risk; your preference for active or passive funds; your ESG/sustainability preference; and your preference for specific themes. Neither are you likely to be asked what future you hope for, beyond growth versus value... nothing imaginative like which Arup scenario you want to invest in, or your interest in specific themes such as the circular economy, electrification, or ecosystem restoration projects.

There is also a fifth question that is not always asked: what level of fees and decision-making are you comfortable with? Having spent a big chunk of my career developing passive ETFs, where the whole ethos is to low fees and investor choice, this strikes me as a fairly central question. Of course, we know that passive investment led to all sorts of distortions, not least the bloated flotation of Thus PLC at the height of the DotCom bubble, a story that is just as relevant today with the boom in US AI stocks.

So with this caveat - that passive ETFs are feeding the US AI bubble - is it even possible to build a low-cost sustainable fund? Or are we entering a new era of wealth managers and financial advisers?

Let's take the first and last questions together - should we all be active investors now? 

Let's start with the FCA evidence that higher fees lead to worse performance, and that passive investment leads to over-weighting of some stocks/sectors and a weakening of stewardship, governance and capital allocation. We'll use that as a guide to ignore active funds, and instead build a low-cost ETF base by choosing a sustainability overlay (benchmarks with stronger stewardship and governance). We'll then use bonds to adjust to our risk preference. Lastly, to be active allocators of capital, we'll keep money aside to make specific allocations in themes that align with our values.

Q1: sustainability preference. Depending how we feel about stewardship and governance, we add a stronger benchmark overlay (such as the exclusion of fossil fuel firms, and strong positive selection) or a weaker benchmark overlay (such as ESG tilts towards improved firms).

Zero ESG base: if we really don't care at all, we just buy the MSCI All World Index.

Low ESG base - conveniently split into US and ex-US, we can use the iShares ESG Aware MSCI EAFE ETF and iShares ESG Aware MSCI USA ETF as our ESG base, boosting ESG scores while staying close to the original index

Medium ESG base - if we want a medium overlay, the iShares MSCI World Screened UCITS ETF will reduce carbon intensity by around 30%, while excluding sectors such as tobacco and thermal coal

High ESG base - for the strongest overlay, basing our portfolio on the Xtrackers MSCI World ESG UCITS ETF will mean investing in a faster transition, reducing carbon intensity by around 50%, plus stricter ethical screens and ESG exclusions

Q2: attitude to risk. Next, we'll include bonds, depending on our risk preference. 

Low risk - don't even think of investing before you have reduced your debts, especially high interest debts such as credit cards

Medium risk - the traditional 60/40 equity/bond portfolio is not entirely dead. Sure, take on as much equity risk as your appetite allows, but include bonds to reduce overall risk. This is an opportunity for active capital allocation, too, by investing in community energy bonds available via an Ethex IFISA, or in tax-free NS&I green savings bonds. Alternatively, invest in UK Gilts to ensure you have cash when you need it - 0-5 year, for short-term cash; or all maturities, for long-term cash. If you like risk, include some corporate or overseas bonds. If you want to keep things simple and liquid, include some Premium Bonds.

High risk - if you really think this time is different, don't bother with any bonds, but max out your property loans and credit cards to invest in the ETFs under Q1. Don't come crying to me if things go badly wrong.

Q3: your preference for specific themes. I'm assuming by now that you've decided on your ESG base - one of the versions of the MSCI All World ESG indices listed above - and you've decided what percentage to put into bonds. There are various ways to bring in additional themes, take your pick:

Country/region themes - it's much easier to add than to subtract, by buying a suitable country ETF. Alternatively, rather than the MSCI All World, look for exclusions such as the iShares ESG Aware MSCI EAFE ETF above, which would reduce your exposure to the US.

Other themes. There are plenty of thematic and impact ETFs out there. The challenge here is to avoid buying into a bubble, and to avoid transaction fees. I set myself a rule to re-balance annually, to keep my transaction costs down. That also forces me to be more like Warren Buffett2, and invest in things where I have a connection or interest... so what does that mean for you? Themed ETFs and community bonds don't just cover sustainable energy but also sustainable food, the circular economy, electrification, commodities, green infrastructure, nature restoration, charities, farms, social enterprises... just remember caveat emptor!